What we will cover:

Are We Making It Too Expensive for Small Businesses to Employ People?

I can remember when I first started employing people back in 2012.

It was a big step. Taking on your first employee is exciting, but there’s also that feeling of responsibility. Suddenly, you’re not just worrying about generating enough income to pay yourself. You’ve got someone else relying on you to pay their wages at the end of the month.

But I do think employing people was a little simpler back then.

We didn’t have the same workplace pension obligations that small employers face today. Employer National Insurance was 13.8%, and the adult National Minimum Wage was £6.19 an hour from October 2012.

Of course, £6.19 went a lot further in 2012 than it would today, and I certainly wouldn’t argue that people should be expected to live on that amount now.

But looking back, the cost of employing someone has changed considerably.

And I can’t help wondering whether we’re reaching a point where employing people is becoming too expensive for some small businesses.

It’s Not Just the Wages

Fast-forward to 2026, and the National Living Wage for employees aged 21 and over is £12.71 an hour.

Employer National Insurance is now 15% on earnings above the relevant threshold, which for most employees is just £5,000 a year.

Then there are workplace pension contributions.

Automatic enrollment actually started in October 2012, but it was introduced gradually, beginning with the largest employers. Smaller businesses generally came into the system between 2015 and 2017, with new employers following their own staging dates.

Today, eligible employees must be automatically enrolled into a workplace pension, with employers generally contributing at least 3% of qualifying earnings.

Now, I want to make something clear.

I support people earning a decent wage, and I think encouraging employees to save towards retirement is a good thing.

But I also understand the pressure these costs place on small business owners.

Because when you employ someone, their salary is only part of what they actually cost you.

There are pension contributions, employer National Insurance, holiday pay, payroll administration, insurance, equipment, training and the time spent managing and supporting them.

And unlike larger organisations, small businesses often don’t have the financial reserves to absorb these costs quite so easily.

What Does an Employee Really Cost?

Let’s take someone earning £30,000 a year.

For an employer paying the standard National Insurance rate, that’s another £3,750 in employer National Insurance before any reliefs.

Add approximately £716 in minimum employer pension contributions, assuming the usual qualifying earnings basis, and the direct annual employment cost is already around £34,466.

That’s before allowing for equipment, training, recruitment, payroll administration and other overheads.

Of course, some employers will qualify for Employment Allowance, which can reduce their overall employer National Insurance bill. But it doesn’t change the underlying cost of employing someone.

And here’s the important part.

That £34,466 needs to be generated by the business, along with enough income to cover all its other expenses and hopefully leave a reasonable profit.

For a small business with two or three employees, that’s a significant monthly commitment.

Who Actually Pays for These Increasing Costs?

Ultimately, somebody has to pay.

When wages, National Insurance, pensions and other overheads increase, businesses have a few choices. They can accept lower profits, try to become more efficient, reduce other costs or increase their prices. And in many cases, increasing prices becomes unavoidable.

A café has to charge more for its food and drinks. A tradesperson increases their hourly rate. A professional services business reviews its monthly fees.

Those increases are then felt by customers, who are often struggling with their own household bills. It’s one of the reasons I think running a small business can sometimes feel like being stuck between a rock and a hard place. You’re trying to pay people fairly, keep your business profitable and remain competitive, all while your customers are looking for value for money.

And there’s another complication.

When prices across the economy rise too quickly, the Bank of England may increase interest rates to try to bring inflation under control.

Higher interest rates make mortgages and borrowing more expensive, leaving households with less money to spend. Businesses may then find that customers are buying less, while loans and overdrafts used to finance growth become more expensive.

The idea is that reducing spending slows demand and eventually helps bring inflation down.

But there’s a difficult balancing act here.

Higher borrowing costs can also put pressure on businesses already dealing with rising wages and overheads. Some may try to recover those additional costs through their prices, although weaker customer demand can make that difficult.

So while higher interest rates can help reduce inflation over time, they can also make investment, recruitment and growth harder in the short term.

And that can leave small business owners wondering when things are actually going to get easier.

And Then There’s the Challenge of Keeping Good People

The cost of employing someone isn’t the only concern. There’s also the investment you make in developing your team.

When you take on a new employee, you spend time training them, introducing them to customers, teaching them your systems and helping them understand how your business operates. It takes time before someone becomes fully productive. And when you run a small business, that training often falls directly on the business owner.

You invest in people because you want them to develop, enjoy their work and hopefully become a valuable part of your business for years to come.

But people move on.

Perhaps they’ve been offered a better salary, want a new challenge or simply feel it’s time for a change. That’s perfectly understandable. People have their own ambitions, and nobody should feel obliged to stay in a job that no longer suits them. But I don’t think people always appreciate the impact losing an employee can have on a small business.

In a large organisation, losing one member of staff might be relatively straightforward to manage. In a business with three employees, losing one means you’ve suddenly lost a third of your team. Someone has to pick up the work. Customers may experience delays, the remaining employees come under pressure, and the business owner often finds themselves back doing the work they thought they’d moved away from.

Recruitment takes time and money, and there’s no guarantee that the next person will be the right fit. Service levels can suffer, workflows are disrupted and, if things aren’t managed carefully, the business’s reputation can be affected.

It’s not simply a case of advertising a vacancy and replacing someone.

Is Outsourcing the Answer?

I think this is why more small businesses are considering freelancers, outsourcing and even offshoring certain parts of their operations.

And I can understand the attraction.

Instead of committing to a full-time employee, a business might engage a freelancer for a particular service or outsource a function to a specialist provider. For example, you might outsource bookkeeping, payroll, marketing, administration or IT support. For service-based businesses, this can offer a degree of flexibility and sometimes greater certainty over costs.

You know what the service is going to cost each month, you don’t necessarily need to provide equipment or office space, and you may have access to a wider range of skills than you could afford to employ directly. If business slows down, some outsourced arrangements can also be adjusted more easily than a permanent staffing commitment, depending on the contract.

Offshoring can offer additional cost savings, although it also brings considerations around communication, quality control, data security and managing people working in different locations.

And outsourcing isn’t without its challenges either.

You still need to manage the relationship, check the quality of the work and make sure customers receive the service they expect. There’s also the question of employment status. Calling someone a freelancer doesn’t automatically make them self-employed for tax or employment law purposes.

I have mixed feelings about the whole thing.

On one hand, I understand why small business owners want flexibility and greater control over their costs. On the other, small businesses are an important source of employment in this country. If more businesses decide that employing people is simply too expensive or too risky, what does that mean for the next generation entering the workplace?

And particularly for young people who aren’t currently in education, employment or training, often referred to as NEETs, where will those opportunities come from? We need businesses that are confident enough to invest in people, offer training and create jobs. But we also need to recognise that those businesses must remain financially viable.

My Five Top Tips When It Comes to Employing Staff

I wouldn’t want any business owner to be put off employing someone simply because of the challenges I’ve discussed. Having a good team can transform a business. It can free up your time, improve customer service and allow you to grow in ways that would be impossible on your own. But I would encourage anyone considering recruitment to think carefully before making that commitment.

1. Understand the true cost of employing someone

Don’t just look at the salary.

Calculate employer National Insurance, pension contributions, holiday cover, equipment, recruitment and training costs. Then work out how much additional income or productive capacity that employee needs to generate to make the position financially sustainable. You might be surprised by the difference between someone’s salary and the actual cost to your business.

2. Check what employer reliefs and support are available

Make sure you’re claiming any reliefs your business is entitled to.

For example, eligible employers can currently claim up to £10,500 a year through Employment Allowance to reduce their employer National Insurance liability. There are conditions, particularly for certain single-director companies, so it’s worth checking eligibility rather than assuming. Also consider whether apprenticeships or training support might be appropriate for your business.

3. Think about whether you need a full-time employee

Before recruiting, ask yourself whether the role genuinely requires someone working full-time. Could a part-time employee meet your needs? Would a freelancer or outsourced service be more suitable?

There’s no right or wrong answer.

It depends on the work involved, the importance of continuity, the level of control you need and the financial position of the business. Sometimes employing someone is absolutely the right decision. Other times, a different arrangement might make more sense.

4. Invest in keeping the people you’ve already got

Recruiting and training replacements can be expensive, so don’t underestimate the value of looking after your existing team. That doesn’t always mean paying the highest salaries. Good communication, flexibility, opportunities to develop and simply making people feel valued can make a real difference. And make sure your systems and processes are documented so the business doesn’t become completely dependent on one person.

5. Make sure your cash flow can support the decision

This is probably my biggest tip.

Before employing someone, prepare a cash flow forecast and look at what the additional monthly commitment will mean for your business. Don’t just assume that because turnover is increasing, you can afford another employee. What happens if you lose a customer? What if sales fall for three months? Could the business still meet its commitments?

I’d also encourage you to review your pricing. If you’re taking on employees to deliver services, your fees need to reflect the true cost of providing those services.

A little planning before recruitment can save an awful lot of worry further down the line.

We Need Small Businesses to Be Confident About Employing People

I don’t believe outsourcing is the answer to everything. There is enormous value in building your own team, developing people’s skills and creating a business where employees feel part of something. I’ve experienced the benefits of having people around me who can take responsibility for work and allow me to concentrate on other areas of the business. But I also understand why some business owners hesitate before taking on another employee.

The financial commitment is significant, the responsibilities are increasing and the consequences of getting it wrong can be difficult for a small business to absorb.

I think policymakers need to consider the cumulative effect of employment costs on smaller employers. It’s easy to announce an increase in wages or introduce another requirement, but somebody has to find the money to pay for it. And for a small business owner, that money doesn’t simply appear. It has to come from sales, profits or savings elsewhere in the business.

We should absolutely want people to earn decent wages, have financial security and enjoy good working conditions. But surely we should also want businesses to feel confident enough to create those jobs in the first place? For me, that’s the balance we need to get right.

So here’s my question. Are we making it too expensive for small businesses to employ people, and could we eventually reach a point where outsourcing becomes the preferred option rather than building a team of employees?

I’d be interested to hear what other business owners think.

Glenn’s Notebook – Business, life and everything in between.

Schedule a Call with Glenn

Glenn Saunders, founder of Swan Saunders

Glenn Saunders accountant

With over 20 years of experience in accounting and financial support, Glenn and his team bring a wealth of expertise to the table. In 2023 Glenn set out to create a firm that goes beyond accountancy, offering common sense advice, coaching, and mentoring to help clients truly understand their businesses.

Empowering Businesses

At Swan Saunders, we provide accounting support that empowers businesses and individuals to know their numbers with confidence. Through coaching, mentoring, and collaboration, we will simplify making success achievable.